Can Soccer Experts Really Predict the Season?

Every summer, soccer analysts, former players, and journalists publish their predictions for how the Premier League table will look when the season ends. These forecasts generate plenty of debate, but they also raise an interesting question: Are expert predictions actually more accurate than simple statistical expectations?

Before the 2014/15 Premier League season, journalist and former player Joe Prince-Wright published his predicted final standings. His projected top six looked like this:

Chelsea

Manchester City

Arsenal

Manchester United

Tottenham Hotspur

Liverpool

Remarkably, those six clubs finished in exactly that order. Among the many preseason predictions made by soccer writers that year, this was one of the strongest performances, especially at the top of the table.

However, the picture became less impressive once the rest of the league was considered. Everton and Newcastle United were expected to finish comfortably in the top half but slipped into the lower half of the standings. Leicester City was tipped for relegation before producing a dramatic late-season escape, while Southampton and Swansea City exceeded expectations by finishing much higher than many experts predicted.

Measuring Prediction Accuracy

One way to evaluate preseason forecasts is to compare each team’s predicted finishing position with its actual position. Across all 20 clubs, the average error in Prince-Wright’s predictions was just over two league positions.

At first glance, that seems like a strong result. After all, teams often move several places in the standings during the final weeks of a season.

But there’s an important benchmark that every prediction should be compared against.

Sometimes the Best Prediction Is the Simplest One

Historical data shows that a team’s finish in one season is often one of the strongest predictors of where it will finish the following year. In other words, simply copying last season’s league table as your forecast for next season can produce surprisingly accurate results.

When the actual 2014/15 standings were compared with the final table from the previous season, the average difference was almost identical to the expert prediction. Many clubs changed very little from one year to the next, making the previous season’s results an excellent baseline forecast.

This means that, while some experts correctly identified a few important changes, much of their apparent success came from the league remaining relatively stable.

How Accurate Are Soccer Pundits?

Analyses of preseason predictions from multiple soccer journalists reveal a consistent pattern. A handful of experts outperform simple historical benchmarks, but most do not.

Many forecasts end up performing no better—and sometimes worse—than a prediction based solely on last season’s standings.

Unexpected events make accurate forecasting extremely difficult:

Injuries to key players

Midseason managerial changes

Breakthrough performances from young talent

Surprise title challenges

Unexpected relegation battles

Fixture congestion and European competition

These factors are nearly impossible to anticipate months before the season begins.

The Challenge of Predicting Soccer

One season may make an expert look brilliant, while the next can quickly expose the limits of prediction.

For example, preseason forecasts for the 2015/16 campaign overwhelmingly favored Chelsea to defend its title, while Leicester City was widely expected to battle relegation. Instead, Chelsea struggled throughout the season, and Leicester produced one of the greatest underdog stories in sports history by winning the Premier League.

Results like these demonstrate why long-term forecasting remains so difficult. Even knowledgeable analysts cannot consistently account for the countless variables that influence a soccer season.

What Can Bettors Learn?

For bettors, preseason predictions should be viewed as informed opinions rather than reliable forecasts.

Historical performance, underlying team quality, player transfers, and advanced statistics all provide useful information, but no expert can consistently predict exactly how an entire season will unfold.

The lesson is simple: while soccer analysts can offer valuable insight, the sport remains wonderfully unpredictable. That’s one of the reasons fans continue to watch—and why betting markets are constantly adjusting as new information emerges throughout the season.